LeRoy French - Underwater Stills and Videos and video sales

Underwater Photographer

Back to List of Articles

“Shark Feeding”

environmental issues This activity called ‘shark feeding’ has been a controversial subject for a number of years. Is it good or bad? Does it harm the ecosystem? How does it affect the sharks? We will address these questions in this article. First of all let me qualify myself as a person who has the authority able to answer these questions. I have been on many shark feeding excursions from the Caribbean Reef shark to the Great White Shark. I have filmed these animals up close and personal and can attest to the fact that I have had a close encounter with a Great White a number of years ago.

Here in St. Maarten and the Caribbean the most common shark for this activity is the Caribbean Reef Shark. This is the most abundant shark in the area and often participates in feeding programs. This shark is not known to be aggressive toward humans. I have studied these shark feeding programs in different parts of the world and can safely say that it is neither good or bad depending on your point of view. There is concern that sharks become dependent on these hand outs and may associate food with humans. Proponents argue that sharks are taking advantage of a free lunch and after the feeding is over go back to feeding on whatever they fed on before. This is very true as I have seen at the end of the program the sharks disperse in all directions. However, like all animals who are used to being fed at a certain time in a certain place, once again the Pavlovian response comes into effect. The shark hears the boat returning daily to the same area and naturally he comes to see if he is going to be fed. There is no proof that the small amount of sharks being fed around the world are responsible for any bathers being attacked. It is important to know that individual sharks receive very little food, therefore they do not rely on humans for providing their meals. Because of this the ecosystem is left intact.

environmental issues The behavior of the shark is changed very little. Regularly fed sharks will appear on queue as we mentioned when they here the boat approaching, but after receiving a few scraps return to their normal activities.

Shark feeding operators in a small way are protecting the sharks and the ecosystem at the same time. Its not compulsory to feed sharks to protect them but who else will champion these animals?

Shark feeding programs also allow photographers to get images to educate the public in shark behavior and dispel the fears that this is the creature of a nightmare.

In my opinion, responsibly conducted shark feeds, complete with good shark biology and conservation message are educational and reasonably safe. All of the feeds that I have been on have been located away from populated areas and beaches. The only time the shark is threatened is when fisherman target a shark feeding area. Then the entire population can be wiped out.